About this blog..

This is a blog that I started in April 2006, just after I first put on my bogu (kendo armour). It collects the advices given by more experienced kendo practitioners as well as those from my own experiences. Both technical and the mental aspects of kendo are written in the blog. I hope someone will find them useful or interesting at least!

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Reviews on kendo books

I wrote some reviews and critics on the several kendo books that I have, in case someone needs them before making a decision on which one to go for. This was originally motivated by a thread in the kendo world forum.

The books I review here are, in order:
  1. Kendo: The Definitive Guide by Hiroshi Ozawa
  2. Kendo: Elements, Rules and Philosophy by Jinichi Tokeshi
  3. Looking at a Far Mountain: A Study of Kendo Kata by Paul Budden
  4. The Heart of Kendo by Darrell Max Craig
  5. The Way of Kendo and Kenjitsu by Darrel Max Craig
I will maybe add some more information when I have more time, or when ideas come into my mind.


==============================
Kendo: The Definitive Guide
by Hiroshi Ozawa
==============================

Written by Prof. Ozawa, a professor a the Tokyo University of Science, and the head sensei of Kobukan kendojo. It is a well structured book aimed on beginner and intermediate kendo players. I imagine advanced kendo players can also benefit from having an instructive book for teaching, as well as the sections on refereeing and correct training mentalities.

It contains a brief history of kendo, maintenance of the equipments, the fundamentals of kendo (inc. Kata), and a comprehensive well-structured description of the wazas. The author, being a 7th Dan Kyoshi and an experienced kendo instructor, included an unique section on the best mindset for improving kendo. He travels regularly overseas to hold international seminars.

This book is a very comprehensive kendo handbook that any kendo enthusiast alike would find it helpful to have on the shelf.

I personally look into it when something didn't work out in the training, and I cannot get an useful advice from the instructor.


================================
Kendo: Elements, Rules, and Philosophy (Latitude 20 Book)
by Jinichi Tokeshi
================================

This book is written in clear language, and explains the basic concepts well, but the weakness is that, the techniques are sometimes too abstract. The footworks in waza (or techniques) are not explained. For this purpose, I recommend "The definitive quide".

This book however contains some (6 pages) on nitto-ryu. But it's mostly for curiosity as for beginners, it's not so useful. Another unique section is the personages of some kendo masters. It's good if you want to know about more the historical development of kendo. It contains a chapter on kendo philosophies and concepts, with the Japanese idioms explained. It is good for your kendo as well as personal development.

============================
Looking at a Far Mountain: A Study of Kendo Kata (Tuttle Martial Arts)
by Paul Budden
============================

Though I haven't read in detail this book, since I don't spend much time on Kata. But in my opinion, this is a good book focused on Kata, which can compliment any general kendo textbook. It contain the historical evolution of the kendo Kata (with nice old photos). The Kata are explained in good detail, with breathing methods, and illustrated with nice photos.

=============================
The Heart of Kendo: A Comprehensive Introduction to the Philosophy and Practice of the Art of the Sword
by Darrell Max Craig
=============================

Semi-biographic. Some sections. Having alread "The Definitive Guide" I sometimes do wonder why I got this book. (In fact this book was given as a gift). There is a chapter on his conversations with the author's late sensei. Sometimes it feels like a long ramble, when the author asks "But Sensei, why?" over and over again, and the sensei says "Well, this is simply so. Don't you think?"A such example is:

Graig: Sensei, I'd like to ask a question.
Sensei: I know.
Graig: I'm sorry.
Sensei: I know. What is your question?
...


Not terribly exciting is it? I much prefer a concise writing rather than that of a transcript type. The conversation was also somewhat stiff. The basic waza is not described as systematic and comprehensive as in "The Definitive Guide".


==============================
The Way of Kendo and Kenjitsu: Soul of the Samurai
by Darrell Max Craig
==============================

Some sections overlap with the earlier book "The Heart of Kendo". I do not see the point of having a book, which is aimed at advanced kendo players, that contains still the very basic parts such as etiquette, equipment, and basic exercises.

The most valuable parts of the book are on the advanced techniques, for example, tsuki, which the author explained with finer details. The techniques covered were not comprehensive, but with a bit of thinking, the reader can apply similar principles to the other techniques.

The rest of the book contains kenjutsu and kendo kata, as well as personal stories. The stories are readable, though not terribly exciting.

Not suitable for beginners and maybe not the best for intermediate players. But it is a nice book if one likes to expand his/her variety of "arsenals".

Apart from the sections on the advanced waza, I almost never read the other parts of the book.

2 comments:

Mark said...

TNX for the review. It realy helped me. As a beginner I'm going for The Definitive Guide.

Anonymous said...

XpnSoz [url=http://nba27.webnode.cn]英超直播[/url] InoIsn [url=http://nba28.webnode.cn]新浪NBA直播吧[/url] MnsCkk [url=http://nba29.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播视频[/url] RtcSpm [url=http://nba30.webnode.cn]NBA直播视频直播[/url] VnsFfm [url=http://nba31.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播[/url] GufXca [url=http://nba32.webnode.cn]NBA直播湖人[/url] MezEip [url=http://nba33.webnode.cn]英超宝贝[/url] ZgqLyj [url=http://nba34.webnode.cn]天下足球直播[/url]
FjrXlh [url=http://nba35.webnode.cn]NBA直播视频直播[/url] KmjVbm [url=http://nba36.webnode.cn]新浪体育NBA直播[/url] PmyVfc [url=http://nba37.webnode.cn]新浪NBA直播吧[/url] PhuXal [url=http://nba38.webnode.cn]吻球网足球直播[/url] XfkIek [url=http://nba39.webnode.cn]天下足球直播[/url] DxpYzi [url=http://nba40.webnode.cn]NBA直播视频直播[/url] IfrSzt [url=http://nba41.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播视频[/url] XafAqr [url=http://nba421.webnode.cn]英超直播[/url]

TwrUln [url=http://nba197.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播视频[/url] NcaNms [url=http://nba20.webnode.cn]NBA直播吧[/url] MgcWlw [url=http://nba21.webnode.cn]NBA直播吧[/url] PitRtf [url=http://nba22.webnode.cn]NBA直播表[/url] NkrGkb [url=http://nba230.webnode.cn]英超直播[/url] WivRbk [url=http://nba249.webnode.cn]天下足球直播[/url] QvfVby [url=http://nba25.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播视频[/url] OlbEkg [url=http://nba26.webnode.cn]英超直播[/url]
[url=http://tt2929.com/]百家乐[/url]
[url=http://tt5252.com/]太阳城娱乐城[/url]
ZmfEqf [url=http://nba115.webnode.cn]新浪NBA直播吧[/url]PeuFwh [url=http://nba12.webnode.cn]英超联赛[/url]AqpMwy [url=http://nba13.webnode.cn]吻球网足球直播[/url]MdmAua [url=http://nba14.webnode.cn]新浪NBA直播[/url]ZcyNvb [url=http://nba15.webnode.cn]吻球网足球直播[/url]LomJjg [url=http://nba16.webnode.cn]风云足球直播[/url]JnbVld [url=http://nba170.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播[/url]OjwJkq [url=http://nba18.webnode.cn]腾讯NBA直播[/url]